As retirement approaches—or settles in—many people start looking for guaranteed income they can’t outlive. Market swings feel riskier, savings feel more fragile, and budgeting on a fixed income becomes harder after age 65.
That’s when annuities often enter the conversation. But with high fees, complex rules, and mixed opinions, many retirees wonder:
Is an annuity worth it for retirement income, or is it a costly financial mistake?
Let’s break it down so you can compare annuities to other retirement income strategies and decide if one fits your money and investment plan.
What Is an Annuity?
An annuity is a financial product sold by insurance companies. You invest a lump sum (or a series of payments), and in return, the insurer promises to pay you income—either immediately or in the future.
Common types of annuities include:
-
Immediate annuities (income starts right away)
-
Deferred annuities (income starts later)
-
Fixed annuities (guaranteed rate)
-
Variable annuities (income tied to investments)
-
Indexed annuities (linked to market indexes with limits)
Each comes with different costs, risks, and income guarantees.
Why Retirees Consider Annuities After Age 65
After age 65, priorities often shift from growth to stability. Retirees consider annuities because they can:
-
Provide predictable monthly income
-
Reduce fear of outliving savings
-
Simplify budgeting on a fixed income
-
Offer protection from market volatility
For people without a pension, annuities can feel like a “do-it-yourself pension.”
The Real Cost of Annuities
Understanding the cost is crucial before deciding whether an annuity is worth it.
Common Annuity Costs
-
Commissions and sales fees
-
Annual administrative fees
-
Investment management fees (for variable annuities)
-
Rider costs for guarantees or inflation protection
-
Surrender charges for early withdrawals
Some annuities are low-cost and simple. Others are expensive and complex, which can reduce long-term income.
Is an Annuity Worth It Financially?
The answer depends on how you plan to use it and which type you choose.
An Annuity May Be Worth It If:
-
You want guaranteed lifetime income
-
You worry about outliving your retirement money
-
You lack a pension
-
You prefer stability over maximum investment growth
-
You can lock away funds without needing flexibility
In these cases, an annuity can reduce financial stress and act as a foundation for retirement income.
An Annuity May NOT Be Worth It If:
-
You need access to your money
-
You’re comfortable managing investments
-
Fees significantly reduce returns
-
You already have strong guaranteed income (pension + Social Security)
For some retirees, the cost outweighs the benefit.
Annuity vs Other Retirement Income Options: How to Compare
Before buying, it’s smart to compare annuities to other finance strategies.
Annuity vs Investment Portfolio Withdrawals
-
Annuity: Guaranteed income, limited flexibility
-
Investments: Higher growth potential, market risk
Annuity vs Dividend Income
-
Dividends: Flexible, market-dependent
-
Annuity: Stable but usually less liquid
Annuity vs Bond Ladders
-
Bonds: Predictable income, interest-rate risk
-
Annuity: Longevity protection, insurer-dependent
Each option impacts your retirement money differently.
Taxes and Annuities
Tax treatment depends on how the annuity is funded:
-
Qualified annuities (IRAs): Fully taxable as income
-
Non-qualified annuities: Only the earnings portion is taxed
While annuities offer tax deferral, they do not receive capital gains treatment like some investments.
How Annuities Fit Into a Retirement Finance Plan
Annuities work best when used as part of a broader retirement plan—not the whole plan.
Many retirees use annuities to:
-
Cover essential expenses (housing, food, utilities)
-
Combine them with Social Security for baseline income
-
Use investments for discretionary spending and growth
This layered approach balances security and flexibility.
Common Myths About Annuities
“All annuities are bad.”
Some are expensive; others are simple and effective.
“Annuities are investments.”
They’re insurance products designed for income, not growth.
“You lose your money if you die early.”
Many annuities offer survivor or period-certain options.
Final Verdict: Is an Annuity Worth It for Retirement Income?
An annuity can be worth it for retirement income—especially after age 65—if your priority is guaranteed, predictable money you can’t outlive.
It’s most suitable for retirees who:
-
Value income security over flexibility
-
Want protection against longevity risk
-
Can afford the cost without straining cash flow
It’s less ideal for those who want full control, low fees, and growth-focused investing.
Before buying, compare products carefully, understand surrender rules, and consider independent financial advice. The right annuity can bring peace of mind—but the wrong one can quietly drain your retirement money.
